Compared

Colossus vs spreadsheets

Most associations we talk to keep their members in a spreadsheet or an ageing database, take bookings on an events site, send email from a mailing tool and chase payments somewhere else. It works until the membership, the renewals or the team grows. Here is what a spreadsheet set-up does well, where it breaks, and what changes when the members, renewals, events and CPD records live in one system.

Colossus membership management, reporting and revenue tools
Side by side

What you are comparing

A spreadsheet set-up here means Excel or Google Sheets for the member list, plus the mailing tool, events site and card processor most organisations put around it.

ColossusA spreadsheet set-up
Member recordsOne record per member, with the application, renewals, bookings, CPD and payments on it. Everyone works on the same record.One row per member, edited by hand. A second version appears as soon as two people need the sheet at once.
RenewalsReminders go out on the schedule you set; the invoice, the online payment and the lapsed-member list follow without anyone filtering a column.Renewal dates in a column, reminders written and sent by hand, lapsed members found by filtering and remembering.
PaymentsCard payments through Stripe and invoices raised against the member record, so who has paid is on the record.Bank transfers matched by hand against the sheet, or a card link pasted into an email.
Events and bookingsBookings, tickets and attendance on the member record, with member pricing applied automatically (from the Growth plan).An events site with its own attendee list, copied back into the sheet after the event.
CPD and coursesCPD records, courses and certificates in the member portal (from the Growth plan).A folder of certificates and a column of hours.
Member portalMembers update their details, renew, pay and download invoices themselves.None: members email the office to change an address or ask for an invoice.
EmailSent from the same records, segmented by membership type, renewal date or event.A mailing tool fed by a list exported from the sheet, out of date the day it is exported.
ReportingMembership, renewals, income and engagement reports from live data.Pivot tables when someone has the time.
Access and GDPRNamed staff logins with roles, and one place to answer a subject access request.One file shared by email or a drive; nobody knows how many copies exist, and a subject access request means searching every one.
Set-up and migrationDiscovery, configuration, a test import of your spreadsheet and training. Standard migration from one principal source is included with the Switch & Grow offer.None: you already have it.
CostFrom £349 a month (Core): 3 full staff licences, up to 5,000 active members, 12-month agreement. No per-member fees.Included in Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace. The mailing tool, the booking fees of the events site and the card fees are extra, and so is the staff time.
01

Stay on spreadsheets if

You have a few hundred members or fewer, one person runs the membership, everyone renews on the same date once a year and nobody needs to log in. A well-kept sheet and a mailing tool will do, and the money is better spent elsewhere.

02

Choose Colossus if

You have a membership team, thousands of members, renewals through the year, events, CPD or payments to run, and the same questions keep coming back: who has paid, who has lapsed, who attended, and which version of the sheet is the right one.

03

Moving from a spreadsheet

Send us the sheet. In discovery we map its columns to the member record, run a test import for your team to check against the original, then the final import before launch. One principal data source is covered by the standard migration.

Plans

What Colossus costs instead

Every plan is priced by full staff licence with an active-member allowance. Members, applicants, learners and event attendees are never charged. Prices are in GBP with VAT shown separately, on a 12-month agreement; the full detail is on the pricing page.

PlanA monthFull staff licencesActive membersBuilt for
Core£3493 includedUp to 5,000Smaller associations and professional bodies moving away from spreadsheets or an outdated database.
Growth£6995 includedUp to 20,000Established organisations running membership, events, learning and engagement from one platform.
Scale£1,2998 includedUp to 50,000Larger professional bodies with qualifications, approvals, integrations or reporting to run.
Enterprise£2,500+15 includedTailoredNational, international or multi-entity organisations with a tailored agreement.
Questions

Spreadsheet or membership software?

Is a spreadsheet good enough for a membership organisation?
For a small one, yes: a few hundred members, one administrator and one renewal date a year. The sheet starts to cost you when two people need it at once, when renewals roll through the year, or when members expect to renew, pay and update their own details online.
What does it cost to move from a spreadsheet to Colossus?
The Core plan is £349 a month with three full staff licences and up to 5,000 active members, on a 12-month agreement. The standard migration from one principal source, usually the spreadsheet itself, is included with the Switch & Grow offer. There are no per-member fees, so the price does not change as the membership grows.
Will we lose data in the move?
No. Every column is mapped in discovery, a test import is run for your team to check against the sheet, and only then is the final import run. You keep the spreadsheet; after launch it is the archive, not the system.
Can we try it with our own spreadsheet first?
Yes. The free trial runs for 30 days and needs no card details. Most organisations also book a demo so we can walk through their renewals, events and CPD flows with their own data.

See your spreadsheet as a membership system

Book a demo around your membership model, or start a 30-day free trial - no card details needed.

Prices are those published on the pricing page on 1 November 2026. See also Colossus vs Wild Apricot, Colossus vs MemberClicks, Colossus vs i4a, Colossus vs MemberMojo, Colossus vs sheepCRM, Colossus vs White Fuse, Colossus vs VeryConnect and Beacon CRM alternatives, or all our comparisons.